Our Full Menu

Discover Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza Menu

Name: Anthony's coal fired pizza
Address: 137 Old Country Rd, Carle Place, NY 11514, USA, United States
Telephone: +1 516-877-7750
Price range: $$

Authentic anthony's coal fired pizza crafted in our signature coal-burning oven — delivering bold, smoky flavors on every pie, pasta, and plate. Browse our full selection and place your order today.

Order Now View Menu

Coal Fired Pizzas

8 signature varieties

Pastas & Mains

Slow-crafted recipes

Salads & Starters

Fresh daily

Home
Menu

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizzas

Fired at 800°F in our signature coal oven — crispy, charred, and impossibly flavorful

Margherita coal fired pizza with fresh tomato and mozzarella

Classic Margherita

San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh fior di latte mozzarella, torn basil, extra virgin olive oil. The timeless coal fired classic.

$17.99

Anthony's signature coal fired pepperoni pizza

Chef's Pick

Anthony's Pepperoni

Double-layered pepperoni cups, whole milk mozzarella, house tomato sauce. Our coal oven curls the pepperoni to perfection.

$21.99

Coal fired white pizza with ricotta and garlic

White Coal Bianca

Creamy ricotta base, garlic, fresh spinach, roasted cherry tomatoes, shaved Parmesan. A coal fired white pizza indulgence.

$22.99

Truffle Mushroom

Wild mushroom medley, black truffle oil, fontina cheese, caramelized onions, fresh thyme. An earthy, luxurious combination.

$25.99

New

Smoky BBQ Chicken

Slow-pulled chicken breast, housemade BBQ drizzle, red onion, smoked gouda, cilantro. Bold meets the coal-fired heat.

$23.99

Spicy Italian Sausage

Housemade fennel sausage, Calabrian chili, roasted peppers, provolone, fresh parsley. A perfectly spiced coal oven creation.

$23.49

Anthony's Pizza Starters

Begin your meal the right way with our coal-kissed starters and appetizers

Fan Favorite

Coal Fired Wings

Eight slow-roasted chicken wings finished in the coal oven, served with house-crafted blue cheese and celery sticks.

$14.99

Vegetarian

Classic Bruschetta

Grilled sourdough, vine-ripened tomatoes, fresh basil, aged balsamic reduction, roasted garlic. A bright and satisfying starter.

$10.99

Burrata & Heirloom Tomatoes

Imported burrata, colorful heirloom tomatoes, fresh pesto, finishing salt, EVOO, arugula. A show-stopping opener.

$15.99

Try Anthony Coal Fired Pizza Catering

Planning an event? We bring the coal fired experience to your venue. Ask us about catering packages.

Order Now

Anthonys Coal Fired Pastas & Mains

Hearty Italian-inspired pastas made with the same coal fired intensity we bring to every dish

Best Seller

Rigatoni Bolognese

Slow-cooked beef and pork ragù, rigatoni pasta, Parmigiano-Reggiano, fresh basil. Simmered for hours, served with love.

$19.99

Vegetarian

Cacio e Pepe

Tonnarelli pasta, Pecorino Romano, coarsely cracked black pepper, butter. A minimalist Roman classic at its finest.

$18.49

Shrimp Scampi Linguine

Wild-caught shrimp, linguine, white wine garlic butter, lemon zest, cherry tomatoes, fresh parsley. Elegant and bright.

$24.99

Anthony's Coal Fired Salads

Fresh, crisp and bright — perfectly complementing any coal fired main

Classic

Classic Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine hearts, housemade Caesar dressing, shaved Parmigiano, housemade croutons, cracked black pepper.

$12.99

Vegetarian

Arugula & Pear Salad

Baby arugula, sliced Bosc pear, gorgonzola crumbles, candied walnuts, honey-lemon vinaigrette. A harmonious balance of flavors.

$13.99

Coal Grilled Chicken Salad

Coal-grilled chicken breast, mixed greens, avocado, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, lemon-herb vinaigrette. Light yet satisfying.

$16.99

Anthonys Pizza Sweet Endings

Complete your anthonys coal fired experience with our handcrafted Italian desserts

House Made

Classic Tiramisu

Layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers, velvety mascarpone cream, dusted with fine cocoa. Made in-house daily.

$9.99

Signature

Nutella Coal Calzone

Freshly baked pizza dough folded over Nutella and ricotta, dusted with powdered sugar, served with vanilla gelato.

$11.99

Vanilla Panna Cotta

Silky vanilla bean panna cotta, fresh mixed berry coulis, toasted almond crumble. A delicate Italian classic.

$8.99

Beverages & Drinks

Curated drinks to elevate your anthony's coal fired dining experience

Italian Sparkling Water

San Pellegrino sparkling mineral water. 500ml bottle.

$3.99

Fresh Mint Lemonade

Freshly squeezed lemons, mint, cane sugar syrup, chilled. Refreshing and bright.

$4.99

House Italian Red Wine

Curated Italian Montepulciano d'Abruzzo. Glass pour. Ask about our bottles.

$9.99

Espresso & Cappuccino

Freshly pulled Italian espresso or frothy cappuccino. The perfect end to your meal.

$4.49

Ready to Place Your Order?

Visit us at 137 Old Country Rd, Carle Place or call us to place your order today.

+1 516-877-7750

Order Now Contact Us